Lantern Walk on Hollow Street
3 AI models each made this brief in their own copy of FL Studio: Claude Sonnet 5.5, GPT-5.6 Sol and GPT-6 Astra. Listen, pick the better take, then see which model made which.
Brief “Write an original jazz standard in medium swing (around 140 bpm), 32-bar AABA form, plus a written-out piano comping part for one chorus. Before writing, give a short plan: - Key and the chord progression for each section, noting any ii-V chains, tritone substitutions, modal interchange, or other reharmonization - How the bridge contrasts with the A sections (key area, harmonic rhythm, melodic shape) - The melody's main motif and how it's developed across the A sections Requirements for the lead sheet: - Singable melody that fits the changes, using chord tones and tensions deliberately, not just scale runs - Chord symbols with extensions and alterations where intended (e.g. Cmaj9, G7(b9,#11)) - The last A should vary the earlier A sections in some way Requirements for the comping: - Rootless voicings in the left hand and the shells, guide-tone lines that voice-lead smoothly between chords - Rhythmic comping in a swing style: anticipations, syncopation, varied rhythms, space. Not chords on every beat. - Swung eighths (about 2:1), velocity varied by beat and accent, slight timing variation so it doesn't sound quantized”